If you want your eyeliner to stay put all day (and night!), these five pencils are game-changers. Revlon’s ColorStay Waterproof offers bold, smudge-proof color, while e.l.f.’s No Budge is cruelty-free and easy to apply without worry. NYX’s Mechanical Pencil gives you precise lines that resist heat and humidity, and Wonderskin’s Longwear performs beautifully in rain or tears. Curious about which one suits your style? Keep going—you’ll discover all the insider tips next!
REVLON ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner with Sharpener
Looking for a pencil eyeliner that stays in place all day? The REVLON ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner with Sharpener delivers. It lasts up to 24 hours and resists transfer, smudging, and fading. You can create a subtle line or a bold look easily with this glide-on pencil. It has a built-in sharpener to keep the tip sharp and lines crisp. The formula is safe for sensitive eyes and works well on the waterline. No need to worry about reapplying—this eyeliner holds up rain or shine.
Best For: People who want long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner that works all day and is safe for sensitive eyes.
Pros:
- Lasts up to 24 hours, is waterproof, transfer-proof, and smudge-proof
- Glides on easily for precise lines, with a built-in sharpener and smudger
- Safe for sensitive eyes and suitable for the waterline
Cons:
- Only comes in 12 shades, which may limit choices
- Needs sharpening often, which can cause product waste
- Some users find the pencil softer, making it harder to control for delicate lines
Revlon ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner (2 Pack)
If you want long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner, try the Revlon ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner (2 Pack). It provides bold color that lasts up to 24 hours. The formula glides on easily for smooth application. You can create simple lines or bold, dramatic looks with it. The eyeliner has a built-in sharpener for precise lines and a smudger to blend colors. It comes in 12 different finishes, such as matte and shimmer, for different styles. It is safe for the waterline and tested by ophthalmologists. This makes it a reliable choice for all-day wear.
This eyeliner is best for people who want a long-lasting, waterproof product that is easy to apply. It stays put without smudging or fading all day. The built-in sharpener and smudger help you get precise and blended looks quickly. With many finish options, you can use it for a natural or bold style.
Some drawbacks include needing a sharpener to keep the tip sharp. A few users find the product too soft or creamy when first applying. It is waterproof, which can make it harder to remove compared to regular eyeliner.
e.l.f. No Budge Waterproof Eyeliner, Black
e.l.f. No Budge Waterproof Eyeliner in Black provides a bold look that lasts all day. The creamy formula delivers intense color with a single swipe. It is waterproof and smudge-proof, so it stays in place through sweat and tears. The pencil is easy to apply to the lash line, waterline, or eyelids. It is vegan and cruelty-free, making it a good choice for ethical beauty. The eyeliner is simple to use and designed to last, helping you create dramatic or everyday styles easily. It prevents smudges and fading, so you can feel confident all day and night.
Best For: People who want a waterproof, long-lasting eyeliner that is easy to use and makes a bold statement.
Pros:
- Creamy, highly pigmented for vivid color
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear
- Vegan and cruelty-free, respecting ethical standards
Cons:
- Might need a sharpener for precise lines
- Difficult to remove without a makeup remover
- Limited shade options, mostly black
NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil – Onyx Black Eyeliner
No products found.
The NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil in Onyx Black is a practical choice for everyday eyeliner. It is a retractable pencil that does not need sharpening. You can easily twist it up to reveal more product. The pencil applies smoothly, with a creamy texture that glides over the eyelid. It provides bright, intense color that looks like liquid eyeliner in a quick swipe. The design helps keep your hands clean and prevents messes. This eyeliner is smudge-proof and stays in place even in heat or humidity. It works well for daily wear and long-lasting looks. The product is cruelty-free and simple to use, making it perfect for those who want fast, reliable results.
Best For: People who want a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner that is easy to apply without sharpening.
Pros:
- Bright, vivid color with a shiny finish
- Creamy texture for easy application
- Resists smudges, heat, and humidity for all-day wear
Cons:
- May need multiple coats for very bold lines
- Less precise than sharpened pencils for detailed designs
- The twist-up mechanism might not last long with frequent use
Wonderskin Waterproof Longwear Black Eyeliner Pencil
Are you looking for an eyeliner that lasts all day? The Wonderskin Waterproof Longwear Black Eyeliner Pencil offers 24 hours of bold color. It does not smudge, transfer, or fade. The waterproof and transfer-proof formula works well during busy or active days. You can use it as eyeliner or eyeshadow. The TruGlide Technology makes application smooth and easy. It glides on without pulling the skin. The pencil is vegan and cruelty-free, so it is a good choice for ethical beauty.
This eyeliner is ideal for people who want a long-lasting, smudge-proof black liner. It provides versatile use and is cruelty-free.
Pros:
- Provides 24 hours of vibrant, fade-proof color.
- Waterproof and transfer-proof.
- Easy and smooth to apply thanks to TruGlide Technology.
Cons:
- May need sharpening to keep a fine tip for detailed lines.
- The black color might be too intense for soft, natural looks.
- Removing it fully may require makeup remover.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Pencil Eyeliners That Don’t Smudge
When picking a pencil eyeliner that stays put all day, you want to check its longevity and wear power—no one likes a raccoon look before lunch! Waterproof formulas are your best friends for smudge-proof perfection, so look for those magical claims. Plus, easy application tools, vibrant color options, and a good sharpener or blending tool can turn your eyeliner game from blah to wow—because fabulous eyeliner should feel effortless!
Longevity and Wear
Long-lasting pencil eyeliners help you achieve perfect, smudge-free eyes all day. These liners resist fading and smudging for up to 24 hours. You can focus on your day without worry. For extra staying power, choose waterproof or transfer-proof formulas. These types stand up to weather and active days. Ingredients like silicones and film-forming agents create a barrier that keeps the liner in place. Use tools like smudgers and sharpeners for precise application. The creamy but firm texture makes it easy to apply smoothly. This helps you get a sleek look that stays put. Say goodbye to raccoon eyes with these durable eyeliners.
Waterproof Formulas
If you have struggled with smudged eyeliner during the day, waterproof formulas can help. These eyeliners are made with water-resistant ingredients. They resist sweat, tears, and humidity. Because of this, your eyeliner stays in place all day. Waterproof formulas use special polymers and silicones. These create a flexible barrier on your skin. This barrier prevents the eyeliner from breaking down. The formulas are made with oil-in-water emulsions. These emulsions help the product resist heat and emotional moments. To remove waterproof eyeliner, use an oil-based makeup remover. This gentle removal prevents irritation near your eyes. Waterproof pencils provide long-lasting and reliable wear. They help you feel confident that your eyeliner will not run or smudge. Waterproof formulas make it easier to maintain a clean, polished look all day.
Smooth Application
Choosing a pencil that glides smoothly over your eyelids makes applying your makeup easier and more precise. Look for a creamy texture; it should move easily without pulling or skipping. Sharp pencils help create crisp, defined lines that stand out. Choose formulas that contain hydrating or smoothing ingredients; these make application feel soft and comfortable. Using a primer or a base eyeshadow can help the pencil glide even better and give you cleaner results. High pigment quality ensures the color appears bright and is easy to blend evenly. With the right pencil, you can create a flawless eye look quickly. A smooth, easy-to-apply pencil helps you achieve a beautiful, smudge-proof finish every time.
Color Intensity Options
For color intensity, choosing a pencil eyeliner changes your look. Light shades create a natural look. Dark shades add drama. You find many colors, from soft neutrals to bright hues. Pigment level shows how bright or subtle the eyes look. Creamy formulas give vivid, strong color. Matte finishes are understated and good for daily wear. Shimmer or metallic shades add brightness and sparkle for special events. Some pencils allow layering, letting you build up color from light to bold. Whether you pick classic black or bright colors, the right intensity helps you show your style confidently. Smudge-proof formulas keep your look neat all day.
Sharpener and Blending Tools
A built-in sharpener on your eyeliner pencil keeps the tip precise. It helps you draw clean, sharp lines easily. A small smudger tool is useful for blending or softening the line quickly. Sharpening the pencil regularly removes dull tips and excess product. This helps the product go on smoothly and stay in place longer. Good blending tools like brushes or sponges make your look seamless. They help create smooth transitions and soft edges. Avoid harsh lines and smudges with these tools. When shopping, choose eyeliners with a sharpener and smudger. These features help your makeup stay sharp and flawless all day.
Sensitive Eye Compatibility
If your eyes get irritated easily, don’t worry. Many pencil eyeliners are made for sensitive eyes. Look for labels like ophthalmologist-tested. This shows eye doctors checked the product and approved it as safe. Choose formulas that are hypoallergenic. They do not contain fragrances or parabens. These ingredients can cause irritation. Pick eyeliners with soothing ingredients. They help reduce redness and soreness. Waterproof and smudge-proof types stay on well. They also help prevent irritation if you tear up. Find a creamy texture. It glides on gentle and easy, without pulling or hurting delicate skin.
Ethical and Cruelty-Free
Choosing a cruelty-free pencil eyeliner means making a kind choice. When a brand is certified by PETA or Leaping Bunny, it shows no animals are harmed. These eyeliners avoid animal ingredients and use vegan formulas. This makes your beauty routine match your values. Many brands use eco-friendly packaging to help the planet. These ethical eyeliners go through safety tests to ensure they are safe for sensitive areas, like your waterline. You can enjoy a beautiful, smudge-proof look while being gentle on animals and the environment. Making this choice benefits your conscience and the planet.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Long Do Smudge-Proof Pencil Eyeliners Typically Last?
Smudge-proof pencil eyeliners typically last about 8 to 12 hours, depending on skin type and application. You can enhance longevity by applying primer beforehand and setting with translucent powder for all-day wear.
Are Waterproof Eyeliners Suitable for Sensitive Eyes?
Yes, waterproof eyeliners are generally suitable for sensitive eyes because they often contain gentle formulas that resist irritation. However, you should check ingredients and do a patch test first to guarantee your eyes remain comfortable.
Can Pencil Eyeliners Be Easily Removed Without Harsh Makeup Remover?
Yes, pencil eyeliners can usually be removed easily with gentle makeup remover or micellar water. You might also use a cotton swab or soft cloth to gently wipe away the product without irritating your sensitive eyes.
Do These Eyeliners Work Well for Shaping and Watercolor Effects?
Yes, these eyeliners work well for shaping and watercolor effects. You can easily blend them for softer looks or build up layers for more defined, vibrant lines, making them versatile tools for creative makeup styles.
How Do I Prevent Eyeliners From Skipping During Application?
To prevent eyeliners from skipping, you should start by sharpening your pencil for a precise tip, apply a primer or use a damp brush on the liner for smoother application, and gently warm the pencil beforehand.
